Skip to main content

Technical note on ETFs



I’ve often said that I am a terrible stock picker.  I don’t believe in stock picking, for every good pick there is the equivalent terrible selection.  What makes a good stock trader is not his ability to pick winners, but to have the guts to “cut-out” the losers quickly, and I am crap at that part of the equation!

Anyway, my favorite stock investment instruments are ETF – Exchange Traded Funds that allow me to take position in virtually any global strategy (did very well for a while investing in Taiwanese stocks as a proxy for China).  Funny enough the first ever ETFs were invented in Canada – really, but the real big ones are the QQQQ, spiders etc that provide access to some of the biggest stock plays in the world (in the case of the above two:  Nasdaq top 100 stocks and the S&P500).  The reason I like ETFs is that since I am a terrible stock picker (alpha) the way I make money in the stock market is following the trend of the market in general (beta).  The other attractive feature of ETF is that they are easy to buy have very lower management fees (most) and brokerage fees are minimal as they can easily be bought using a discount brokerage account.

Anyway, being somewhat involved in the financial market I kind of know how ETFs are made, especially I know how they are made in Canada – most of the ETFs are made by the book runner buying and selling the underlying stocks – that way the ETF tracks the index (more or less).  However, to reduce the tracking errors (because different stocks have different volatility coefficients -- it gets complicated here) derivatives are used here.  That way if you buy the ETF for the S&P/TSX 60 your tracking error may be as small as 25/35 bps (1/3 of 1%).  However, in Canada there are liquidity issues (Canada is a small market) about 10-12% of any specific ETF assets will be derivatives (instead of the underlying stock).  In the U.S. where liquidity is much higher (and we are talking orders of magnitude here!) maybe 5% of each ETF is made up of derivatives – and for the really big ones (QQQQ & SPY) it is probably lower (less then 1%).

In Europe the proportion of derivatives is much higher.  Primarily for fiscal efficiency it is efficient to use derivatives instead of the underlying equities; as much as 50% of the average ETF is made up of derivatives.  The issue with derivatives is counterparty credit risk.  Not only is there a risk vis-à-vis the sponsor but also towards his own derivative counterparty.  Moreover, whereas the sponsor of the ETF in North America is usually an independent firm (free to replace the book runner) in Europe the Sponsor and the book runner are one in the same.

I’m not saying that investors should avoid European ETFs, but I wonder how many investors realize that whey the buy the ETF for the CAC40 they are in fact taking a great deal of European bank risk, with virtually no recourse to the assets of these firms (they become an unsecured creditor).  Anyway it gives everyone something to ponder on this Thursday morning.

Popular posts from this blog

Spray painting Taylor Swift G650 aircraft (updated)

 First, a bit of paint will not harm anyone.  These climate activities are going to learn two things in the next few days:  (1) Trespassing at an airport is a felony almost anywhere in the world.  That means criminal prosecution.   (2) removing paint from an aircraft is expensive.   So these climate activists are about to find out the reach of the British criminal system and it will not be pleasant, the UK has very strict laws about that, I would be surprised if cleaning the aircraft of all the paint will cost less than $100,000.     I am sure that when they planned (premeditation) this little show they had a very valid logic to doing this.  Tonight, they are probably realizing the depth of their troubles.   I understand that in the UK it's a minimum one-year jail sentence.    Also, good luck travelling with a criminal trespass charge against you.  I am relatively certain that the airline industry will ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Farm; Half year performance

 People appear to be genuinely curious. 2024 has been a record first half for the farm.  The addition of high tunnels has greatly impacted our revenues.   While we expected Q1 profits to be higher, it really was the second quarter that produced the goods.  The terrible weather has greatly impacted the production of high-end vegetables. Energy costs are now very stable and have become a fixed variable especially now that our bio digesters are fully dialled in.   Replacing some of our pre-dryer equipment was covered under warranty, and the new equipment is far better at dealing with gas moisture, and much better steel!   Our diesel costs are what they are! Our biologist and ecologist devised a new planting plan for our high tunnels that greatly reduced pests, especially slugs.   We have seen a 90% decline in sluggs this year, resulting in better yields.   It seems that several plants act as natural repelants and if planted c...
Post a Comment
Read more

Britain, France and Egypt

 The voters realize now that the Conservative Praty desire to return to 19th-century dominance has driven its hatred of the EU.  The voters realize now that departure from the EU has accelerated Britain's decline and may soon make it irrelevant.  At best it will have to kiss American arses to maintain its standing.  For this, the conservatives were punished.  The decline of Britain was inevitable, competition from Frankfurt and Germany in Finance was bound to grow.  The core of Europe (aka Germany) is aging quickly Macron seems to be winning his bet, the left alliance that won the legislative elections will not remain united for long, since they disagree on about everything.   The Far right though it was about to assume power is once again relegated to the back of the bus.   It may draw its own conclusions, but not all of these are good for France.  The far-right has won nearly 1/3rd of the electorate, that is not something to be ig...
Post a Comment
Read more